Just Deserts

Just Deserts

Some thinkers argue that our best scientific theories about the world prove that free will is an illusion. Others disagree. The concept of free will is profoundly important to our self-understanding, our interpersonal relationships, and our moral and legal practices. If it turns out that no one is ever free and morally responsible, what would that mean for society, morality, meaning, and the law? Just Deserts brings together two philosophers – Daniel C. Dennett and Gregg D. Caruso – to debate their respective views on free will, moral responsibility, and legal punishment. In three extended conversations, Dennett and Caruso present their arguments for and against the existence of free will and debate their implications. Dennett argues that the kind of free will required for moral responsibility is compatible with determinism – for him, self-control is key; we are not responsible for becoming responsible, but are responsible for staying responsible, for keeping would-be puppeteers at bay. Caruso takes the opposite view, arguing that who we are and what we do is ultimately the result of factors beyond our control, and because of this we are never morally responsible for our actions in the sense that would make us truly deserving of blame and praise, punishment and reward. These two leading thinkers introduce the concepts central to the debate about free will and moral responsibility by way of an entertaining, rigorous and sometimes heated philosophical dialogue. What emerges is a clear account of the latest thinking on free will, and what is at stake for our moral and legal practices.


Author
Publisher Polity
Release Date
ISBN 9781509545766
Pages 200 pages
Rating 4/5 (6X users)

More Books:

Just Deserts
Language: en
Pages: 200
Authors: Daniel C. Dennett
Categories: Philosophy
Type: BOOK - Published: 2021-02-16 - Publisher: Polity

Some thinkers argue that our best scientific theories about the world prove that free will is an illusion. Others disagree. The concept of free will is profound
Just Deserts
Language: en
Pages: 200
Authors: Daniel C. Dennett
Categories: Philosophy
Type: BOOK - Published: 2021-01-14 - Publisher: John Wiley & Sons

The concept of free will is profoundly important to our self-understanding, our interpersonal relationships, and our moral and legal practices. If it turns out
Natur und Freiheit
Language: en
Pages: 3850
Authors: Violetta L. Waibel
Categories: Ethics
Type: BOOK - Published: 2018 - Publisher:

This volume collects the plenary, main and session lectures of the 12th International Kant Congress 'Nature and Freedom' at the University of Vienna from Septem
Rejecting Retributivism
Language: en
Pages: 280
Authors: Gregg D. Caruso
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 2021-03-22 - Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Within the criminal justice system, one of the most prominent justifications for legal punishment is retributivism. The retributive justification of legal punis
Developmental Coaching: Working with the Self, 2e
Language: en
Pages: 272
Authors: Tatiana Bachkirova
Categories: Psychology
Type: BOOK - Published: 2022-03-04 - Publisher: McGraw-Hill Education (UK)

Examining the self is at the heart of coaching and this book provides a comprehensive overview of knowledge on the Self from psychology, philosophy and other di
The Oxford Handbook of Moral Responsibility
Language: en
Pages: 776
Authors: Dana Kay Nelkin
Categories: Philosophy
Type: BOOK - Published: 2022 - Publisher: Oxford University Press

The Oxford Handbook of Moral Responsibility is a collection of 33 articles by leading international scholars on the topic of moral responsibility and its main f
Free Will and Responsibility
Language: en
Pages: 394
Authors: John S. Callender
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 2010-04-29 - Publisher: Oxford University Press

intuitive sense of freedom be reconciled with causal determinism? How can moral judgment and punishment be compatible with the belief that the events that are h
Restorative Free Will
Language: en
Pages: 328
Authors: Bruce N. Waller
Categories: Philosophy
Type: BOOK - Published: 2015-10-22 - Publisher: Lexington Books

Restorative Free Will argues for an account of free will that takes seriously the evolutionary development of the key elements of free will. It emphasizes a bio
Free Will Skepticism in Law and Society
Language: en
Pages: 254
Authors: Elizabeth Shaw
Categories: History
Type: BOOK - Published: 2019-08-31 - Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Brings together leading philosophers and legal scholars to explore the practical implications of free will skepticism for law and society.
Constitution 3.0
Language: en
Pages: 271
Authors: Jeffrey Rosen
Categories: Political Science
Type: BOOK - Published: 2011-11-11 - Publisher: Brookings Institution Press

At the beginning of the twenty-first century, breathtaking changes in technology are posing stark challenges to our constitutional values. From free speech to p